Whiskey Tramp 026: Michter’s
December 8th, 2009 Posted in Food & Drink, Style | No Comments »
With this post, we’re going to try and revise slightly the way we do whiskey reviews. Whether or not I will sustain this remains to be seen (probably not), but we’re going to try and provide a little more information about what we’re drinking — not just how it tasted, but also the history of the distillery or bottler, and any other pertinent nonsense of which we can think. After all, if you wanted to drink whiskey just for the whiskey, you probably wouldn’t be coming to websites and reading about the stuff. The whiskey nerd in all of us is what brought us here, and collecting esoteric facts are almost… almost… as much fun as the drinking itself.
Michter’s. Seen it on the shelves plenty of times. Had it on a list of things to try, possibly buy, if the price was right. And I never got around to it, for no particular reason other than we are spoiled for choices and my list of things to taste is long. Then a friend brought a bottle of Michter’s 10 year old bourbon to my birthday party this past summer, and between three of us, we managed to drain the bottle in relatively quick order. Quick enough that I didn’t actually remember to take note of particulars, and whatever notes I would have kept would have probably been useless anyway, as the Michter’s was not the only nor even the first thing we drank in moderately excessive quantity that night.
Luckily, this past weekend, there was a Michter’s tasting at Crush Wines in Manhattan, and after a quick detour to the wrong train (getting on the downtown 6 is such an automatic after-work function for me that I do it even when I’m supposed to get on the uptown 6 to go do something instead), I swept in all out of breath and ready to sip some whiskey. The lad who was pouring was nice enough, but his knowledge of the product in particular and whiskey in general was suspect. But you need to learn to roll with these things and pepper your corrections and lectures with honey, provided you can pepper things with honey.
The only thing I knew about Michter’s beforehand, other than that I drank about a third of a bottle in one sitting over the summer, was that it had, at one point, been a Pennsylvania whiskey. So I decided to learn more, especially since Michter’s claims, among other things, to be America’s oldest whiskey, dating its founding way back to 1753. Such claims are always dubious, mostly marketing spin, and occasionally outright bullshit. Some time ago, we did our best to trace the convoluted claims of Rebel Yell bourbon, and also similar to how it seems like every bourbon in existence was “one of only four bourbons that was legally distilled during prohibition.” Michter’s claims to a heritage dating back to 1753 are just as dicey… perhaps even more so.
Read the rest of this entry »
Tags: Bourbon, Michter's, Rye, Tasting Notes, Whiskey, Whiskey Tramp



